Bagel Lady Cafe – Brookhaven, NY: Hours, Menu & Directions

Opening hours

Eastern Time

Checking hours…

Monday	5:30 AM – 4 PM
Tuesday	5:30 AM – 4 PM
Wednesday	5:30 AM – 4 PM
Thursday	5:30 AM – 4 PM
Friday	5:30 AM – 4 PM
Saturday	5:30 AM – 3 PM
Sunday	5:30 AM – 3 PM

72 hours a week across 7 days. Holiday hours may differ.

Tap for directions

99 Ny-25a #18, Brookhaven, NY 11786

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps

Address99 Ny-25a #18, Brookhaven, NY 11786

Phone(631) 744-0071

StyleBagel shop

CountySuffolk County

Time zoneEastern Time

From city center11 mi northeast

About Bagel Lady Cafe

Bagel Lady Cafe serves Brookhaven from 99 Ny-25a #18, 11 mi northeast of the Brookhaven city center. Besides being a bagel shop, it is also listed as bakery café.

It is one of 25 bakeries and sweet shops we list in Brookhaven — about one per 19,710 people living in the city. The closest neighbour on our map is Tilda's Bake Shop, 0.4 mi away.

Bagel Lady Cafe opens as early as 5:30 AM and stays open until 4 PM on its longest day, for about 72 hours across 7 days a week. Weekend visits work too — it is open Saturday and Sunday.

At a glance

Listed as	Bagel shop and Bakery café
Opens earliest	5:30 AM
Closes latest	4 PM
Days open	7 / 7
Bakeries in Brookhaven	25
Nearest bakery	0.4 mi

Suggest an edit

What to order

Typical items at a bagel shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Classic bagels

Pumpernickel bagelDark, rye-based bagel deepened with molasses, offering an earthy, slightly sour flavor and a tight, chewy crumb.
Egg bagelGolden-yellow bagel enriched with eggs for a softer, richer crumb and a faintly sweet, brioche-like flavor.
Plain bagelBoiled-then-baked ring with a shiny, blistered crust and dense, chewy interior; a clean base for any spread or sandwich.
Everything bagelTopped with sesame, poppy seed, dried garlic, onion and coarse salt for a savory, crunchy crust in every bite.

Specialty bagels

Salt bagelPlain dough heavily crusted with coarse pretzel salt; bold and briny, and especially good with a smear of butter.
Whole wheat bagelMade with stone-ground whole wheat flour for a nuttier taste, darker crust and slightly denser, more rustic chew.
Blueberry bagelPurple-tinted dough studded with dried blueberries, sweet and fruity; usually paired with honey or strawberry cream cheese.
French toast bagelSweet bagel brushed with cinnamon sugar and a touch of maple flavor, tasting like diner French toast in ring form.

Cream cheese & spreads

Lox spreadWhipped cream cheese blended with chopped smoked salmon, giving a salty, smoky spread without a full lox sandwich.
Vegetable cream cheeseCream cheese folded with finely diced carrot, celery, bell pepper and radish for crunch and a garden-fresh taste.
Honey walnut cream cheeseSweet cream cheese swirled with honey and chopped toasted walnuts; rich and crunchy, best on cinnamon raisin.
Strawberry cream cheesePink, fruity spread made with real strawberry pieces, light and sweet against a plain or blueberry bagel.

Typical busy times

5 AM9 AM1 PM5 PM10 PM

Estimated from the opening hours and typical bakery traffic — not live data.

When to go

Weekday mornings are usually the rush, peaking around 7 AM.
For the widest choice, arrive within the first hour after opening — popular items can sell out by early afternoon.
The last hour before closing tends to be quiet, and some bakeries discount day-old bread then.

Full hours

Photos

All photos

Bagel Lady Cafe in Brookhaven, NY — Bagel Lady Cafe

Pastries with coffee, Roti'O, Surabaya Pasarturi, 2025 (01) — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Pastry & coffee served at Café Coffee Day — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Tartine New Orleans - Bakery cafe - interior, 11 January 2024 - Aisle — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review

No reviews yet. Been to Bagel Lady Cafe? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about Bagel Lady Cafe

What are Bagel Lady Cafe's hours?

Bagel Lady Cafe's listed hours are Mon–Fri: 5:30 AM – 4 PM; Sat–Sun: 5:30 AM – 3 PM. Holiday hours can differ.

Is Bagel Lady Cafe open on Sunday?

Yes. On Sundays it is open 5:30 AM – 3 PM.

What time does Bagel Lady Cafe open in the morning?

The earliest listed opening time is 5:30 AM on Monday.

Where is Bagel Lady Cafe located?

Bagel Lady Cafe is at 99 Ny-25a #18, Brookhaven, NY 11786. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.

What is the phone number for Bagel Lady Cafe?

The listed phone number is (631) 744-0071.

What should I order at Bagel Lady Cafe?

As a bagel shop, typical picks include Pumpernickel bagel, Egg bagel, Salt bagel, and Whole wheat bagel. See the full menu page for more.

What other bakeries are near Bagel Lady Cafe?

Nearby options include Tilda's Bake Shop (0.4 mi), Tilda's Bake Shop (1.5 mi), and Broadway Market (1.5 mi).

Bakeries near Bagel Lady Cafe

Tilda's Bake Shop45 Route 25A, Shoreham

0.4 mi awayBakery

Tilda's Bake Shop640 Rt-25a, Rocky Point

1.5 mi awayBakery

Broadway Market643 Broadway In between Prince Rd and, King Rd, Brookhaven

1.5 mi awayBakery

Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe379 Ny-25a, Brookhaven

2.5 mi awayBagel shop

Fresh & Hot Bagels346 Ny-25a, Rocky Point

2.5 mi awayBagel shop

Pride Enjoy6302 NY-25A Ste 2 Building C, Riverhead

2.6 mi awayBakery

Wildcat Bagel Deli6243 Ny-25a, Riverhead

2.9 mi awayBagel shop

A Pinch of Sprinkles Bake Shoppe & Confectionery Studio Inc5768 NY-25A Ste A, Riverhead

3.8 mi awayCupcake shop

All bakeries in Brookhaven25 bakeries on one map Bagel ShopsFind more near you Open right nowBakeries open at this moment near you